When Elam wakes up after having fought a bear and won, he is taken in by a local tribe. They believe his success against the bear means he now has the powers of the bear -- a useful thing to have on their side should they attack a Union garrison. For his part, Elam seems to have lost his identity and revels in becoming "Bear Killer" for a time before a fur trapper recognizes him and a white woman taken prisoner by the tribe seeks his aid in her escape.
Erik and Justin discuss how Hell on Wheels tends to be described as "a show you can watch" and the problem of prestige TV production values. Justin points out the lack of series star Anson Mount while Erik suggests the lack of white faces and the usual Hell on Wheels format earned the episode its low IMDb rating. Archie Andrews' bear mauling also comes up. The use of make-up effects gets praise, as does director Clark Johnson's eye for action. The pair attempt to figure out what a 19th Century "Karen" would be, and Justin gets to use his history degree for a good purpose.